Homemade NY Style Pizza is your favorite pizzeria pizza made at home, with a thin chewy crust, tangy tomato sauce, salty & stringy cheese, and enough oil to need some napkins. It also uses the shortcut of using premade pizza dough.Jump to Recipe
Coming from New York, one of the things I miss the most is the pizza. It took some years to find places around the Washington, DC area to compare to the NY pizza we love from home – so, in the meantime, I practiced and practiced how to make this elusive dinner myself.
Every Friday here, usually without fail, is pizza night (more specifically pizza and movie night!). It's easy enough to assemble after a long week or quickly enough for the weekend. I never want to cook on Fridays, but this comes together in 20 minutes, in one pan, takes hardly any effort, and tastes just like real comfort food, but is actually quite healthier than pizza you would buy.
I’ve experimented with flavors like pesto and pepperoni, margarita with fresh tomatoes, and Chicago deep-dish…the list can go on and on. But, first back to the reason I started making pizza – to emulate the New York style from home. While the reason it’s so great used to be explained by the mineral amount in NY water, that’s now considered a myth by some. Several reasons to explain why it tastes so good are the ovens used, the high-quality ingredients, and higher levels of gluten resulting in a chewier crust. Read more here.
Homemade NY Style Pizza
To start, I obviously can’t use water from 250 miles away. Sometimes I make my own dough, but typically I’m in a rush and use good quality store-made pizza dough. Store-bought pizza dough won't result in the same quality and chewiness of dough from scratch, but some techniques get it really close.
Next, I try to use leftover homemade sauce, but good quality tomato sauce like Rao's is also fantastic. Higher quality jarred sauce vs lower quality can make all the difference. For the cheese, I use nonfat shredded mozzarella, plus grated parmesan to give it a more complex flavor. Last, the high temperature allows the dough to become crisp & chewy, not soggy or doughy, while the cheese gets all bubbly.
Start by letting the dough come to room temperature. Then set it in a bowl, rubbed all over with olive oil (so it doesn’t stick as it rises), cover with a dark kitchen towel, in the darkest corner of your kitchen for 1.5-2 hours. I set my dough up before I leave for work and let it rise during the day, so when I come home it's ready to be used. Once the dough has doubled in size, take it out of the bowl and put it onto a pizza pan or stone sprayed with nonstick spray.
Preheat your oven to 450 degrees. Then gently start kneading your dough by holding it in the air and using your knuckles, work around the edges. Be careful to not let the middle get too thin because it will rip. Once you get it stretched a decent amount, you can lay it flat and start working around the edges – from the middle out. The warmer and longer the dough has had to rise, the more pliable it will be.
Next, in a small bowl, combine all of the spices and olive oil and brush onto the dough. This gives the crust some extra flavor. Spread a thin layer of sauce right on top; you need way less sauce than you think. Spread grated mozzarella all over and top with the parmesan. Bake for 15 minutes. The pizza is done when cheese is browning and bubbly and the dough has puffed up and is becoming golden. Let the pizza cool for 5 minutes before slicing. Top with some fresh basil.
AS ALWAYS, IF YOU MAKE THIS – PLEASE LEAVE A COMMENT BELOW!
Homemade NY Style Pizza
- 10 ounce pizza dough
- 2 tbsp olive oil
- ½ tbsp garlic powder
- ½ tbsp parsley
- ½ cup tomato sauce
- 2 cups shredded nonfat mozzarella
- 2 tbsp grated parmesan
- Couple fresh basil leaves
Let the dough come to room temperature. Then set it in a bowl, rubbed all over with olive oil, cover with a dark kitchen towel, and leave for 1.5-2 hours.
Once the dough has doubled in size, take it out of the bowl and put onto a pizza pan or baking sheet sprayed with nonstick spray. Preheat your oven to 450 degrees.
Gently start kneading your dough by holding it in the air and using your knuckles, work around the edges. Then lay it flat and start work from the middle out. Reaching the ends of the pan, creating a crust.
In a small bowl, combine all of the spices and olive oil and brush onto the dough.
Parbake the dough for 5 minutes.
Take out from the oven, and spread a thin layer of sauce onto the dough. Then sprinkle both cheeses evenly overly the sauce.
Bake for 15 minutes. You can finish the pizza off on a high broil to get the cheese to bubble and brown even more.
Finish the pizza off with another drizzle of olive oil and torn basil leaves.
DID YOU MAKE THIS RECIPE?
If you make this recipe or any others on Bite your Cravings, please leave a comment and a rating below! I’d also love to see and feature your delicious creations on my Instagram page, so post your recipes on social media and tag them with #biteyourcravings!